An attorney for Trevor Bauer told a judge Monday that the Los Angeles Dodgers pitcher had every reason to believe that a woman wanted the choking and other rough treatment he gave her in two sexual encounters that led to her seeking a five-year restraining order against him.
Shawn Holley said in opening statements at a hearing in Los Angeles Superior Court that the 27-year-old San Diego woman told Bauer in private Instagram messages that she had “never been more turned on in my life” than when he choked her to unconsciousness during their first encounter in April and wanted more of the same when they got together again in May. Holley said the woman told Bauer in the messages to give her “all the pain.”
The order stems from allegations he choked a 27-year-old woman to the point of unconsciousness and punched her in the face during a sexual encounter earlier this year.
The woman was granted a temporary restraining order until a hearing could be held and evidence presented for a long-term order.
The woman took the stand briefly before the Monday lunch break, and was scheduled to return for the afternoon.
She testified that she was the daughter of a baseball coach and a lifelong fan who rooted for the San Diego Padres. She said that while watching him on TV she was attracted to Bauer and his quirks, including his closing one eye while pitching.
She tagged him in an Instagram story while watching a game with her mother in April, when Bauer was pitching against the Padres. She had no expectation he would respond. But he sent her a direct message 10 to 15 minutes after the game, and the two began messaging each other.
The woman’s attorneys are arguing that she and Bauer had what should be considered a dating relationship, which would make the type of domestic violence restraining order she is seeking appropriate. Attorney Lisa Helfend Meyer emphasized that the two shared intimate details of each of their lives, both in messages before their meetings at his home in Pasadena and in hours of conversation when they were together.
Bauer’s attorneys dispute that, framing the relationship as a casual one based on sex. Holley pointed out text messages the woman sent to friends before she got together with Bauer, saying she was going to “get her hooks in him,” “get in his head” and get sex from him. Holley said she told Bauer in a message that she would have her “feelings button turned off.”
Meyer said the woman was badly shaken after their first encounter, in which she woke from unconsciousness to find Bauer having anal sex with her, which she had not consented to.
But, Meyer said, friendly and gentle communications in the weeks that followed convinced her to go back again.
“She was led to trust Trevor,” Meyer said, “which resulted in serious harm to her.”
Holley, Bauer’s attorney, said that before they began the second time, he asked the woman what was off limits, and she asked only that he not put his fingers down her throat, which he had done the first time, stopping when she asked him to.
Meyer said the woman had severe injuries and emotional trauma following the second meeting, in which she alleges that Bauer punched her in the face, the vagina and the buttocks.
She “felt excruciating pain, unimaginable pain, worse than she had ever experienced,” Meyer said.
She went to a hospital and had a sexual assault exam done by a nurse, and reported the incident to police, Meyer said. She decided to seek the restraining order only when she learned how long the police investigation was likely to take, Meyer said.
The woman grew emotional on the stand as she talked about struggling with alcoholism for a decade, and often experiencing trauma, some of it sexual. She testified that she has been sober since she was 25, though she lost a job helping to run a sober living house because she couldn’t work after the second incident with Bauer.
The Associated Press does not typically identify people who say they have been victims of sexual assault.
Bauer’s legal team also filed a motion to dismiss the order, which was denied Monday. The judge said it needed to be determined whether the encounter was consensual or not, and that she needs to hear the woman’s testimony.
A continuance on the issue is also being discussed. The hearing is expected to take several days.
Meanwhile, the Washington Post reported over the weekend that an Ohio woman sought a protective order against Bauer last year, accusing him of punching and choking her during a sexual encounter.
The Post says they obtained photos of injuries that the woman alleges are from the pitcher. Injury photos allegedly caused by Bauer have been widely distributed in the California case.
Bauer took to social media to deny the Ohio woman’s allegations, also saying the Post ignored evidence and information about the woman’s behavior and opted to run a “salacious” story.
Bauer is currently on paid administrative leave by Major League Baseball while it conducts an investigation.
His leave, which has been extended five times, currently runs through Friday.
The Pasadena Police Department has also been investigating the accusations in California against Bauer.
